What's up with him? I know he was dropped earlier this season but thought he regained his place. He seemed to have a good start for you. As a Hull fan I was sorry to see him go. At Hull he had some weaknesses in defence but was a big powerful runner and an excellent finisher. Given the choice out of Lineham and Westerman I would rather have kept Lineham. I understand Westerman has been very good for you.

Joe Westerman has been great for us with and without the ball. Tom Lineham's defensive frailties are still there. I think Tom needs to work on his application and attitude.

There were rumours that he wasn't the most professional sportsman which irked Radford.

Doubt we'll see him in the 1st team again this year.

Westerman has been superb

He scored a hat trick for the reserves on Saturday. He needs good centre that passes the balll

No doubt he can finish but he needs other players to do all the work. Rugby is a team sport and he's too lazy to get that.

Hmm not really he plays outside a good centre he performs. Of his ten tries in the first game how many were created by his centre.

I don't think dropping him is the answer and I would have penny n Lineham onbthe wings anyday over Russell n Evans we are cutting our nose off to spite are face in thus situation.

Again? The centre thing? A centre doesn't make him any better at anticipating and chasing kicks, or returning balls it taking first runs for quick ptbs.

His try scoring isn't in question, just every other thing.

Exactly. And Evans served him up plenty of ball when they were playing 2 and 3 together. You just have to look at the way our own Kev Penny, or the Pies' Manfredi, a much smaller player, runs the ball back at defences, and then watch Lineham seemingly shamble forward and fall over, almost avoiding 'collision' , to see that something is wrong with his attitude.

I am 95% certain he won't be here next year.

I can't see him being here but not sure who would want him given his current predicament. I've heard Wakey have signed Caton Brown but Salford already have another 2 decent wingers in vidot and Carney. Maybe Hull KR I suppose.

It depends whether anyone will/ can pay the wages we are. I've always wanted him to come good but if it's deemed he isn't even needed with a Wembley final on the cards and playoffs around the corner then something must be seriously wrong and he needs to go. The salary cap means that you can't afford to carry anyone who isn't playing and seemingly won't be considered for the first team.